Chapter 1: The Emerging Conflict

A conflict is escalating within the Bitcoin community. Have you sensed it? In recent years, it has become routine for Bitcoin supporters to defend their cryptocurrency against rival blockchains, often dismissing them outright. This group, known as Bitcoin Maximalists, asserted that Bitcoin stands alone as the superior choice, viewing other cryptocurrencies as mere distractions. If you were a Bitcoin enthusiast, they generally left you alone.

However, the current situation differs significantly. It has been years since the intense discussions surrounding the blocksize wars of 2017, which revolved around the contentious decision to expand Bitcoin's block size to facilitate scaling. This move aimed to enable quicker and cheaper transactions on Layer 1. The debate was fierce and ultimately led to the formation of Bitcoin Cash. While Bitcoin (BTC) has since emerged as the recognized victor of that dispute, the controversy and uncertainty surrounding it were palpable at the time.

Some argue that the blocksize wars fostered the emergence of "toxic" Bitcoin maximalists, who were genuinely concerned about the preservation of Bitcoin as we know it. They fought valiantly for Bitcoin’s integrity and succeeded in safeguarding the protocol. Nevertheless, once the dust settled, these maxis sought new battles to fight, which may explain their subsequent criticism of alternative blockchains.

As time has passed, a faction of prominent Bitcoin maximalists has begun to insist that true enthusiasts must pass a "purity test" to be deemed genuine Bitcoiners. They argue that Bitcoin is sacred and should be utilized solely for specific purposes, such as safeguarding one’s savings and conducting transactions. Activities on other blockchains—like NFTs, DeFi, token minting, airdrops, staking, and yield farming—are viewed as distractions that divert focus from the primary goal: accumulating as much Bitcoin as possible.

Throughout Bitcoin’s evolution, many of these features were not feasible on BTC. This historical context fostered a sense of unity among Bitcoiners, who collectively rallied against users of alternative blockchains.

However, last month marked a pivotal shift with the introduction of Ordinals, allowing NFTs to be inscribed on the Bitcoin blockchain. This development has sparked a significant internal conflict among Bitcoin maximalists, who argue that Bitcoin should serve a singular purpose, viewing NFTs as a misuse of precious block space. In contrast, a new faction is emerging, eager to explore and expand Bitcoin’s capabilities—mirroring the ethos of the early cypherpunks who were initially drawn to Bitcoin.

As Ordinals occupy an increasing amount of block space, transaction costs have surged, leading to frustrations among Bitcoin maximalists. Their primary grievance lies in the permanence of these “useless” NFTs on the Bitcoin blockchain, which they feel tarnishes its pristine nature. This situation has ignited a broader debate about the intended use of Bitcoin.

This pushback stands in stark contrast to Bitcoin’s foundational principles, which celebrated individual freedom and the right to utilize one's assets as one sees fit—as long as transaction fees are covered.

As you may have guessed, I align with the Ordinal proponents in this debate. While I may not be an avid NFT enthusiast and have no plans to purchase them soon, I firmly believe that Bitcoin and cryptocurrency should embody freedom without the need for justification. As long as users are willing to pay transaction fees, I support their choices.

The rise of Ordinals excites me about Bitcoin’s future. The experimentation and innovation surrounding Bitcoin have been sorely lacking in recent years, reminiscent of its earlier days. I envision this moment as a potential turning point in Bitcoin’s narrative, where development is reignited, and enjoyment is reintroduced into the Bitcoin experience.

Which side do you find yourself on in this Bitcoin debate?

The first video, The Secret Battle Brewing Within Bitcoin | Coinage - YouTube, delves into the ongoing internal conflicts within the Bitcoin ecosystem.

The second video, A New War Is Brewing in Crypto - YouTube, explores the emerging tensions as new technologies and uses for Bitcoin challenge traditional views.

Follow me on Twitter

Read my articles first on Medium

Thank you for taking the time to read this!