The Misconception of Medical Error as the 'Third Leading' Cause of Death
Written on
Understanding the Claim
The assertion that medical error ranks as the third leading cause of death in the United States is a frequent topic of conversation whenever the subject of medical mistakes arises. This claim is so prevalent that it appears in television dramas, news articles, and is often referenced on social media to illustrate the failings of the healthcare system.
This argument resonates with many, as there's widespread acknowledgment that the medical field can sometimes inflict harm. Numerous distressing anecdotes exist, particularly concerning vulnerable groups, like women facing inadequate care. Additionally, individuals managing chronic illnesses often recount experiences of potential harm inflicted by healthcare providers, making the notion of medical error as a significant issue seem plausible.
However, the reality is less alarming. While medical error is indeed a concern, it is unlikely to be the third leading cause of death; it probably doesn't even make the top 15.
The Research Behind the Claim
The foundation of this claim lies in a 2016 commentary published in the British Medical Journal (BMJ). The authors compiled various studies examining deaths that could be attributed to medical errors, calculated an average rate from four studies, and applied it to hospitalization statistics in the United States.
In 2013, there were approximately 35 million hospitalizations in the U.S., and the authors estimated a rate of 71 deaths per 10,000 hospitalizations linked to medical errors. They concluded that this would translate to around 250,000 deaths annually, placing it firmly in the third position behind heart disease and cancer.
This figure is alarming, implying that one is more likely to die from a careless medical error than from a firearm or car accident, a notion that is indeed frightening.
Yet, the actual number is likely much lower, and here's why.
Examining the Flaws
One significant issue with the BMJ's conclusions stems from inaccuracies in the data extracted from the studies. For instance, the BMJ cites a 2004 study claiming there were 389,576 deaths attributed to preventable events, yet this figure does not appear in the original paper; the actual number is over 100,000 lower.
Moreover, inconsistencies abound in the statistics presented. For example, the BMJ incorrectly reported that one study indicated 9 deaths related to medical errors when the original study stated only 8. These discrepancies raise concerns about the reliability of the data used to support such a critical claim.
Additionally, the authors extrapolated their findings from a limited set of studies to the entire U.S. population. The studies cited primarily involved Medicare patients—who are predominantly older or disabled—and a small sample of hospitalized patients, making them not representative of the broader population.
In essence, the extrapolation from these biased samples to the entire U.S. population lacks justification.
Further Complications
Another major issue is defining what constitutes a death due to medical error. Clear-cut cases exist—like those resulting from blatant misdiagnoses or surgical errors—yet the BMJ paper suggests a broader definition.
The authors claim that medical error is a significant cause of death in the U.S., but the studies they reference utilize retrospective assessments to determine whether a medical error contributed to a death. Terms like "potentially contributed" or "may have impacted" are used, indicating a lack of definitive causality.
This methodology can inflate estimates of deaths related to medical errors. The BMJ's claim suggests that 30% to 50% of all hospital deaths might directly stem from medical errors, a figure contradicted by higher-quality evidence.
A thorough British review of randomly selected patients found that only 3.6% of hospital deaths were likely tied to avoidable medical issues, indicating that the true rate of deaths caused by medical errors is likely at least ten times lower than the BMJ's estimates.
Conclusion: The Real Impact of Medical Errors
Although the number of deaths related to medical issues is still concerning—estimated at 20,000 to 30,000 annually—it places medical error far lower in the rankings of leading causes of death in the U.S., around the 16th to 20th position.
While it's vital to acknowledge and address the issue of medical errors, the claim that they are a key leading cause of death is misleading. Efforts to reduce medical errors remain essential, but they should not be overstated as a primary cause of fatalities in America.
Investigates whether fatal medical errors truly rank among the top causes of death in the U.S.
Discusses the prevalence of medical errors and their actual ranking among causes of death in America.