Chapter 1: Defining a "Natural Stoic"

You might have encountered the expression "natural Stoic" in discussions about Stoicism. This term is generally used to characterize individuals who exhibit a natural inclination towards Stoic principles. However, it's important to note that many individuals may not fully grasp the philosophical underpinnings of Stoicism when using this label. Furthermore, we must question the utility and relevance of this term.

To better understand what it means to be a "natural Stoic," we should first clarify the essence of Stoicism itself. At its core, Stoicism posits that true fulfillment and success in life stem from being a virtuous person. While there are more intricate definitions available, this straightforward interpretation resonates well with many and captures the philosophy's fundamental essence. Stoics strive to act ethically and speak the truth, engaging in actions that benefit the world as a whole. They contribute positively through their work, kindness, mentorship, and commitment to justice, while also fostering a deep understanding of themselves to better serve the community.

Some argue that, despite these altruistic actions, Stoicism inherently contains a degree of selfishness, as the philosophy aims to cultivate eudaimonia (a flourishing life) for the individual. Yet, I believe that the dichotomy of selfish versus selfless is misleading. Often, people's actions encompass both aspects. For instance, promoting justice not only aids those currently facing injustice but also enhances the likelihood of future justice.

This duality highlights a frequently overlooked aspect of Stoicism: the consideration of time. Stoic actions are not merely about the present; they aim to create lasting positive impacts for future generations. Stoics aspire to foster a good world that endures beyond their lifetime.

While the philosophical exploration of Stoicism is valuable, we must also examine what it means to be a virtuous individual. Stoicism offers four cardinal virtues—justice, wisdom, courage, and temperance—as guiding principles. However, the complexity of life often requires a nuanced approach to balancing these virtues, necessitating independent critical thinking. There is no comprehensive guidebook for navigating every situation; thus, Stoics must rely on their judgment.

Lastly, Stoicism can be succinctly encapsulated by the notion of living in accordance with nature—aligning one's actions with both human psychology and objective reality.

Section 1.1: The Misconceptions of Stoicism

While defining Stoicism is crucial, it is equally important to clarify what it does not encompass. For example, I refrained from discussing the dichotomy of control, which, while relevant, should not be viewed as a foundational concept. This principle is often utilized practically by Stoics but only makes sense when guided by the pursuit of virtue. Without this guiding principle, employing the dichotomy of control lacks the essence of Stoicism, much like prayer in Christianity is significant but does not solely define the faith.

Additionally, I didn't address emotional regulation, which is inherently tied to the virtues of temperance and wisdom. While managing negative emotions is a byproduct of Stoic practice, it is not the primary goal. A person can remain composed without embodying Stoicism; however, embodying Stoicism without aspiring towards virtue is impossible.

Section 1.2: Unpacking the "Natural Stoic"

With these clarifications, we can better understand the term "natural Stoic." This designation does not simply refer to someone who is naturally composed or who focuses solely on things within their control. A natural Stoic is someone who, through an interplay of genetics and socialization, is inclined towards virtuous behavior within the Stoic framework. Given that Stoicism posits that everyone possesses an inherent goodness, one might argue that we all have the potential to be "natural Stoics," albeit to varying degrees.

Subsection 1.2.1: The Role of Genetics and Personality

Genetics plays a pivotal role in shaping our personalities, influencing how we engage with the world. Certain individuals may be more neurotic or empathetic, traits that can steer their actions. For instance, those with higher empathy may be more motivated to act for the benefit of others, thus leaning towards virtue. While these tendencies are not absolute, they highlight how personality can impact one's alignment with Stoic values.

Subsection 1.2.2: The Influence of Socialization

Moreover, the social environment significantly contributes to the development of Stoic values. A person raised in a household that emphasizes courage, justice, wisdom, and temperance is likely to embrace these principles naturally. Additionally, the broader societal context, particularly in the West where Stoic ideas are embedded in philosophical discourse, can facilitate an easier transition to Stoic practices for many individuals.

Chapter 2: Are Natural Stoics Superior?

The question of whether natural Stoics hold an advantage over others is somewhat misguided. The essence of Stoicism is the belief that being a virtuous person leads to happiness. Some individuals may inherit this outlook through genetics or upbringing, but the crucial point is that what matters is not one's origin but the choices made in life. Ultimately, it is not significant whether one is a natural Stoic or not; a Stoic remains a Stoic by virtue of their commitment to the philosophy.

The first video titled "Are You a Natural Stoic? Find Out in 10 Minutes" delves into the characteristics that define a natural Stoic, offering insights and reflections to help viewers assess their alignment with Stoic principles.

The second video, "5 Natural Ways to Make Them Fear Losing You | Stoicism," explores strategies grounded in Stoic philosophy that can enhance personal relationships and personal strength.

Thank you for reading. If you're interested in further insights, consider tuning into The Strong Stoic Podcast, available on your favorite platforms.