Personal Therapy vs. Business Consulting: A Manager's Dilemma
Written on
Chapter 1: Understanding the Dual Roles of Management
My professional journey encompasses two distinct yet interconnected domains: for two decades, I have been the owner and manager of a business, transitioning from hands-on operational management to a more strategic role focused on planning and oversight. Alongside this, I have spent seven years engaged in psychoanalytic and group-analytic practices. The interplay between these experiences enriches my perspective, enabling me to approach both business and psychoanalytic consulting with a broader lens.
Recently, during a gathering with fellow business owners, we engaged in a conversation about the benefits of personal therapy for leaders versus hiring a business consultant. There are numerous viewpoints, but a prevailing sentiment is that it feels more straightforward to invest in a business consultant. This investment is often viewed as a practical choice that can effectively drive business growth and profitability.
However, there is an important caveat: while business owners consciously aim to generate revenue, innovate, and enhance the lives of others, they may also be unknowingly driven by deeper, subconscious motivations. These can include a profound desire for power, a craving for recognition, or even the aspiration to recreate an idealized family dynamic that may have been absent in their childhood. Such underlying motivations can inadvertently obstruct the primary goal of financial success and efficient business operations.
For instance, you might encounter an employee who consistently challenges your authority and fosters a divisive atmosphere among the team. A significant amount of energy may be expended by you and your staff in managing this discord, diverting attention from the core objective of profitability. Alarmingly, if this employee departs, they may be quickly replaced by someone exhibiting similar disruptive behaviors, perpetuating a cycle of negativity within the organization. This pattern often signals that the founder has inadvertently infused their unconscious issues into the company culture. Manifestations of this include:
- The recurring emergence of a "scapegoat" employee who faces hostility from colleagues.
- Persistent conflicts between departments that resist resolution through typical team-building efforts.
- The presence of a feared figure within the team, such as a chief accountant, whose authority instills anxiety even in management.
- Intense competition and power struggles among business partners.
During our discussion, we exchanged insights and personal anecdotes. My own experience illustrates that as I navigated and resolved my internal challenges through personal therapy, the organizational issues my partner and I had struggled with for years began to dissipate. Notably, interdepartmental conflicts lessened, communication improved, and the need for managerial intervention in resolving disputes decreased.
Based on this journey, I firmly believe that personal therapy for business owners can significantly contribute to the overall health of the organization. It allows for a deeper understanding of motivations behind certain actions and offers avenues for informed decision-making. However, this does not imply that hiring business consultants is unnecessary. Consultants are vital for analyzing business processes, offering insights, and assisting in implementation, which can indeed propel your business toward improvement.
That said, if there are underlying motivations that sabotage these improvements, the efforts of consultants may ultimately be futile. Thus, if you find yourself repeatedly inviting consultants without achieving meaningful changes or witnessing cyclical dysfunctions within your team, consider whether these issues are reflective of unresolved aspects you have brought into your business. Beginning a personal therapy journey may not only lead to your own happiness but also enable your organization to break free from these recurring destructive cycles.
Chapter 2: The Impact of Personal Development on Business Success
Section 1.1: The Value of Self-Awareness in Leadership
Navigating the complexities of leadership requires a deep understanding of oneself. Personal therapy can foster this self-awareness, enhancing decision-making and interpersonal dynamics.
Subsection 1.1.1: Recognizing Unconscious Motivations
Section 1.2: Integrating Therapy and Consulting
A holistic approach that combines personal therapy with professional consulting can lead to sustainable growth and improved workplace culture.