Understanding the Experience of Being Trans: A Thought Experiment
Written on
Chapter 1: The Reality of Transgender Youth
Today, I’m accompanying my 22-year-old daughter, who is transgender, to participate in the final day of protests organized by "Trans Kids Deserve Better." This initiative emerged during the summer in response to the UK Government's recent policies concerning transgender youth. Regardless of political affiliations, it is evident that these policies—first implemented by the Conservatives and continued by Labour—curtail the rights of children whose gender identity does not align with the sex they were assigned at birth. These young individuals are now unable to access medical support to delay transition decisions and cannot express themselves freely in schools without the risk of repercussions. Such targeted measures against a minority group have significant implications both within the UK and on a global scale. Every child deserves to feel secure and supported in their journey of identity development, even when that identity diverges from societal expectations.
The ongoing debate often centers on determining what is deemed 'best' for our children, both from medical and social standpoints. Traditional Western ideologies assume a binary classification of male and female, suggesting that individuals should conform to the societal norms tied to their assigned gender. However, these norms have undergone considerable transformation—blue is not exclusively for boys, nor is pink solely for girls (historically, it was the opposite). Additionally, perceptions of gender roles have shifted dramatically; for instance, the antiquated notion that women should remain homemakers and serve their husbands is now largely rejected. Yet, in discussions about gender identity, many still adhere to conventional binary perspectives, which neglect the cultural variances in gender norms. Some societies even celebrate non-binary identities, and it is crucial to recognize the historical existence of transgender individuals who, due to societal pressures, often felt unable to live authentically.
Attending today’s protest prompts me to reflect on the importance of standing alongside my daughter. Although I am neither transgender nor young, and my children are already in their twenties, I witness the injustices faced by these young individuals as they fight for their rights. While they may lack extensive life experience, they possess a profound awareness of their environment and understand how the actions of those who are neither transgender nor allies impact their mental and physical health, as well as their societal acceptance. Thus, they require our unwavering support.
If a reporter were to ask why I am here, I would articulate my response as follows (if I could express it clearly):
“Thank you for your inquiry. The truth is, regardless of what I say, it is unlikely to alter the beliefs of those who have already formed strong opinions regarding transgender rights for children in the UK. Those disengaged from the conversation may cling to their established views, while those already involved may only reinforce their perspectives.
“For those beginning to engage with this critical issue or starting to grasp its significance, I propose a thought experiment. This creative exercise may challenge those unwilling to reconsider their entrenched views. Here it is:
“Imagine waking up to discover that an error was made on your birth certificate. Your parents reveal that you were actually born as the opposite sex, a fact they never disclosed. Medically, you possess the genitals of a male or female, but genetically, you are the reverse. You are then mandated by law to live according to your genetic sex. Despite appearing as a man or woman, you are compelled to live as the opposite gender. You must wear clothing designated for the opposite sex, use their restrooms, participate in their sports, and accept only medical treatments that align with your genetics. How would you feel? What name would you choose? How would others perceive you?
“Feeling vulnerable, you confide in your GP or a teacher. But now, that teacher is obligated to inform everyone at your school, and your GP must discontinue any treatments you were receiving or deny options available to others. Support to help you navigate this new reality will not be accessible for another eight years.
“How would this make you feel?
“This thought experiment, while hypothetical, illustrates the anxiety and emotional turmoil that transgender individuals frequently endure due to societal expectations. It also underscores how policies forcing teachers to act contrary to their better judgment or restricting access to essential medical care can have a profound impact on these children.
“Hopefully, this exercise can cultivate empathy for the transgender community. While some may inevitably misunderstand or misrepresent my statements, I hope it inspires others to reflect more deeply on their beliefs.
“Ultimately, most of us would agree that no one should dictate how another person ought to live or think. So why should anyone impose their views on transgender individuals? Only those with lived experiences truly understand what is right for them. We must listen to their voices and respect their choices. If a request does not harm others, it deserves respect. Yes, there are intricate issues, such as professional sports or gender-specific spaces, but these should be resolved by the relevant communities and governing bodies, not by politicians or outsiders, certainly not by me— and I suspect— not by you either.
“Trans Kids 'DO' Deserve Better.”
In the video "What Being Trans Is Really Like | Get Real | Refinery29," individuals share their personal experiences of being transgender, highlighting the unique challenges they face and the importance of societal acceptance.
Chapter 2: The Journey of Understanding
The second video, "What It's Like Being Transgender (Full Episode)," offers an in-depth look at the lives of transgender individuals, exploring their struggles and triumphs in a society that often misunderstands them.