Defining Success Metrics for YouTube Shorts: A PM Perspective
Written on
Chapter 1: Understanding Success Metrics
Success metrics play a critical role in product management, acting as key indicators that inform whether a product is achieving its intended objectives. For product managers, grasping and articulating these metrics is essential, as they offer a tangible means to track progress, make data-driven decisions, and ensure alignment with overarching business goals.
A prevalent and often challenging question that arises in PM interviews is, "How would you measure success for this product?" This inquiry assesses your ability to think both strategically and analytically about product performance. Interviewers are keen to observe how you define, measure, and evaluate metrics vital to a product's success. Your response reflects not only your comprehension of the product but also your capacity to align it with the organization's objectives.
For Product Managers, it is crucial to articulate how to identify success metrics. As PMs work on various features, they are responsible for establishing the goals and metrics for each feature.
Tackling the Success Metrics Question
When confronted with inquiries about success metrics during an interview, employing a structured method can be immensely beneficial. Here’s a step-by-step guide to navigate these discussions:
Clarify the Question
Begin by confirming your understanding of the question. Don’t hesitate to ask for clarifications if necessary. This demonstrates your attention to detail and eagerness to engage with the topic thoroughly.
Define the Product, Its Users, and Value Proposition
Deliver a concise yet comprehensive overview of the product, its target audience, and the value it provides. This context is crucial for discussing the metrics in a relevant framework.
Identify Core Metrics/North Star Metric
The North Star Metric serves as the primary gauge of the product's success and should correspond with the product's core value proposition and long-term objectives. For example, for a social media platform, this could be "daily active users" or "average time spent on the app per day."
Derive North Star Metrics Using a Metrics Tree
Decompose the North Star Metric through a Metrics Tree. This method involves identifying sub-metrics that directly impact the North Star Metric. For instance, if the North Star Metric is "user engagement," sub-metrics might include "number of posts per user" or "average session duration." This detailed breakdown aids in recognizing what actions can enhance the North Star Metric.
Discuss Counter Metrics
Counter-metrics are vital to ensure that striving for the North Star Metric does not yield adverse outcomes. For instance, boosting user engagement should not compromise user privacy or satisfaction. Counter-metrics help maintain a balanced approach to product growth.
Now that we have a framework for tackling the success metrics question in Product Manager interviews, let's examine a practical case focused on YouTube.
Case Study: Success Metrics for YouTube Shorts
Imagine you are a Product Manager for YouTube Shorts. What success metrics would you prioritize, and how would you define success?
Candidate: Let's focus on YouTube. It has several products, including YouTube Music, YouTube Shorts, and the main YouTube platform. Are we concentrating on one specific product?
Interviewer: Yes, let's discuss YouTube Shorts.
Candidate: Given that YouTube Shorts operates in multiple countries, are we considering metrics on a global scale?
Interviewer: Yes, on a global level.
Candidate: Great! Please allow me a moment to gather my thoughts.
(Candidate notes down key points)
Interviewer: Sure.
Candidate: Here’s how I would approach this problem and identify the right success metrics:
- Understand the company's mission.
- Grasp the product's purpose and identify core metrics.
- Pinpoint North Star metrics.
- Consider counter metrics.
Does this sound reasonable?
Interviewer: Yes, please proceed.
Candidate: YouTube's mission is to empower individuals to express themselves and to showcase diverse content to the world. This mission applies to YouTube Shorts as well. YouTube stands as one of the largest video platforms globally, ranking second only to Google in search engine usage, and it commands a significant share of video viewership.
Recently, TikTok emerged as a strong competitor, capturing a considerable portion of the market share, prompting YouTube to launch Shorts to compete effectively.
Understanding Product Lifecycle
To evaluate our success metrics, we must consider where YouTube Shorts stands within the product lifecycle. Currently, it is in the growth phase.
Interviewer: Why is it important to identify the product's lifecycle stage?
Candidate: Knowing the lifecycle stage helps determine the metrics that the company should focus on. During the growth phase, the priority typically shifts toward Adoption and Acquisition rather than immediate revenue or engagement. Does that make sense?
Interviewer: Yes, please continue.
Candidate: With the product's mission and lifecycle stage established, we should also understand the different user types and the value proposition of YouTube Shorts. It is a platform for short-form videos, primarily featuring vertical content under 60 seconds. Users enjoy quickly browsing through these videos.
YouTube's unique selling proposition is its personalized viewing experience, bolstered by high-quality content. The platform boasts a vast existing user base, offering a competitive advantage.
There are three key user groups for YouTube Shorts: the viewers, content creators, and advertisers. Shorts provide content creators with a platform to reach potential audiences, while viewers enjoy tailored content based on their preferences.
Interviewer: Do these assumptions seem accurate?
Candidate: Yes, they do. Now, let’s define the North Star metrics that will help gauge the overall success of the product. A North Star metric is one that provides insight into the value delivered to all users—viewers, content creators, and advertisers alike.
The value generated can be assessed through the average time spent viewing Shorts, indicating whether users appreciate the recommended content. For content creators, more views signal an opportunity for growth and a voice within the platform, while advertisers benefit from reaching their target audiences.
Therefore, I propose the North Star Metric as:
NS: Average daily time spent viewing Shorts.
Interviewer: Why did you choose a daily measurement?
Candidate: Daily metrics are ideal as monthly or weekly evaluations may delay the detection of any shifts in user behavior. Tracking hourly data is beneficial but should be a secondary focus, evaluated only when fluctuations in daily metrics arise.
Interviewer: Do you believe daily evaluations might sometimes be inaccurate?
Candidate: No, given the fast-paced nature of user behavior with videos, daily metrics are essential. Trends can change rapidly, and waiting a week might result in missed insights.
Interviewer: What factors might influence changes in your success metrics?
Candidate: To ascertain what could impact the success metrics, we need to break them down further:
Average time spent viewing Shorts per day = Number of users on the platform (Shorts) * Average time spent per user = (Number of free users + Number of premium users) * Average time spent per user.
Average time spent per user can be defined as (Average time per session) * (Number of sessions).
Thus, changes in the following metrics could affect our success metrics:
- Number of free users
- Number of premium users
- Average time per session
- Number of sessions
To ensure positive success metrics, we must monitor these variables closely.
Interviewer: Are there any other metrics you would track?
Candidate: In addition to the average daily time spent viewing Shorts, I would also like to monitor:
- Average time spent per user per day
- Daily active users (DAU)
- Average likes on Shorts per day
- Average comments on Shorts per day
- Number of Shorts added daily
- Number of Shorts shared daily
These additional metrics will provide a more comprehensive view alongside the primary success metrics.
Interviewer: Is there anything else?
Candidate: Besides the success and supporting metrics, I would also monitor counter-metrics. Sometimes, success metrics can be misleading. For instance, an increase in daily users might coincide with a drop in the number of Shorts played.
Such shifts in user behavior may not be adequately reflected in success metrics. To counteract this, I will track the following:
- Number of Shorts played daily
- Average time spent per Short daily
- Average number of Shorts viewed per user daily
These counter-metrics will help ensure we remain on the right path.
Interviewer: That was a thorough breakdown and explanation.
Final Thoughts
Success metrics extend beyond mere numbers; they are a reflection of a product's vitality and trajectory. As a Product Manager, your proficiency in defining, interpreting, and leveraging these metrics is pivotal. When articulating your approach to these metrics in interviews, you can distinguish yourself as a candidate who not only comprehends the product but is also committed to its sustainable growth. While many candidates may default to AARRR metrics, presenting a thoughtful, analytical, and user-centric approach to defining success metrics can set you apart in a competitive field.